Copywriting
How to Write Headlines That Make People Stop Scrolling
On average, 8 out of 10 people read a headline. Only 2 out of 10 read the rest. Your headline is not a label for your content — it's your one shot at convincing someone to keep reading. Most small business owners treat it like an afterthought. Here's how to treat it like the job it is.
Why most small business headlines fail
The most common local business headline sounds something like: "Welcome to Smith Plumbing — Quality Service You Can Trust." This fails on three counts: it's generic (any plumber could say this), it's about the business rather than the reader, and it makes no promise the reader actually cares about.
A headline works when it does at least one of these things: makes a specific promise, calls out a specific person, raises a question the reader wants answered, or states something counterintuitive or surprising. If your headline doesn't do any of these, it's invisible.
The 4 headline formulas that consistently work
The "How to [achieve desired result] without [common obstacle]" formula
This is the workhorse of effective copywriting. It works because it acknowledges what the reader wants AND removes their biggest objection in the same sentence. Examples: "How to Get Your Gutters Cleaned Without Taking a Day Off Work." "How to Refinance Your Mortgage Without the Paperwork Headache." The "without" clause is what makes it click — it shows you understand their friction, not just their goal.
The "[Number] [Things] That [Result]" formula
Numbers stop the scroll because they signal structure. A reader knows exactly what they're getting and how long it will take. "7 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Contractor." "3 Signs Your HVAC System Needs Attention Before Summer." The number should feel right for the content — not so small it seems thin, not so large it seems exhausting. 3, 5, 7, and 10 are the numbers that consistently outperform others in click-through testing.
The "Why [Common Belief] Is Wrong (And What to Do Instead)" formula
Counterintuitive headlines generate curiosity. When you challenge something the reader assumes is true, they have to read more to understand how their belief is wrong. "Why Getting the Lowest Quote Usually Costs You More." "Why Most Lawn Care Schedules Are Actually Hurting Your Grass." The key is that the counterintuitive claim must be genuinely true — not clickbait. If the article delivers on the headline's promise, this formula builds trust.
The "The [Role] Who [Did/Avoids] [Something Relevant]" formula
Calling out your specific audience in the headline dramatically increases relevance. "The Homeowner's Guide to Spotting Foundation Problems Early." "What Every Restaurant Owner Should Know About Their Hood System." When the right person reads a headline that names their role, they instinctively lean in — this was written for me. The specificity of "homeowner" or "restaurant owner" actually increases readership among the target audience compared to generic phrasing.
The 5 rules for writing any headline
- Write the headline last. Write your content first, then come back and write a headline that accurately represents the most compelling thing in it. Headline-first usually produces generic headlines because you haven't yet discovered the most interesting angle.
- Write at least 5 options before choosing one. Professional copywriters write 10–25 headline variations for every piece of content. Most local business owners write one. The fifth headline is almost always better than the first. Force yourself to generate options.
- Make a specific promise, not a vague one. "Improve Your HVAC Efficiency" is weaker than "Reduce Your HVAC Bill by 20% This Summer." Specific beats general every time in headlines. If you can put a number, a timeframe, or a named location in the headline, do it.
- Keep it under 70 characters for social media and Google. Beyond 70 characters, headlines get cut off in search results and on most social platforms. Short headlines that pack a full promise outperform long ones.
- Test two headlines when you can. Facebook ads, Google ads, and most email platforms let you test two versions of a headline. The winning headline from an A/B test tells you something true about what your audience responds to — and you can use that insight across your other marketing.
Applying this to your social posts and website
Every piece of content you create has a headline — even if you don't think of it that way. Your Facebook post's first line is a headline. Your website homepage's first sentence is a headline. Your Google ad's first line is a headline. The same principles apply everywhere: be specific, address the reader's interest directly, and make a clear promise about what they'll get from reading further.
The business that invests 15 minutes writing 5 headline options for every social post will consistently outperform the one that writes the first thing that comes to mind. At scale, headline quality is one of the highest-leverage copywriting improvements available to a local business with limited marketing resources.
Want marketing content that actually gets read and drives action?
Anchor Co Media writes social media content, website copy, and blog posts for local service businesses — optimized to stop the scroll and start conversations. Let's put your marketing to work.
Talk to us → See pricing